Travelling by air can be a thrilling experience, soaring through the skies to your next adventure or family visit. But for some, like Virgin Australia passenger Mark Trenwith, the journey can turn into a nightmare when luggage is damaged beyond repair. Mark’s unfortunate experience with his ‘crushed’ suitcase after a domestic flight from Adelaide to Melbourne has sparked a renewed call for a major overhaul in how airlines handle passenger claims and compensation.
Mark’s story is a familiar one for many travellers. Upon retrieving his suitcase from baggage claim, he immediately noticed something was amiss. The suitcase, which had served him well, was now wonky and refused to wheel properly. A closer inspection revealed a more disheartening truth: the entire case had been crushed. The damage rendered his luggage unusable, turning a routine flight into a frustrating ordeal.
Navigating the airline’s claims process proved to be a challenge in itself. Mark described the procedure as ‘laborious,’ involving a trip to the police station to obtain a statutory declaration. The hoops he was made to jump through felt excessive, especially when the outcome seemed uncertain. ‘Why have these processes and hoops to jump through when they’re not going to actually follow through on anything reasonable?’ Mark lamented.
Initially, Virgin Australia’s response to his plight was to offer a mere $75 in compensation, a sum that Mark viewed as a token gesture to dismiss his claim. Considering his suitcase cost $219, this left him out of pocket for the replacement. ‘The bare minimum is you expect to just get your bag back working,’ Mark argued. ‘When it comes back unusable, you just think to yourself, well, this is what I paid for… if you crash someone’s car, you need to pay for it.’
Persistence paid off for Mark, as he was eventually offered full compensation of $219 after the media intervention. However, his story is not an isolated incident. Michael Pascale, a Qantas passenger, endured an 18-month saga to recover compensation for his lost suitcase, which had embarked on an unintended global tour. His perseverance led to a court victory and a $2,700 settlement, but it also highlighted the need for a more robust system to protect passenger rights.
Australia currently lacks an independent airline regulator, a gap that leaves passengers like Mark and Michael with few options but to navigate a complex and often unsatisfactory claims process. Victoria Roy, a spokesperson for the Australian Lawyers Alliance (ALA), has pointed out that Australia is ‘very far behind’ in this regard. An independent regulator or ombudsman could provide a streamlined framework for consumers to enforce their rights without resorting to costly and complicated litigation.
The stories of Mark and Michael are rallying cries for change. They underscore the importance of having a single, clear, and fair system that holds airlines accountable and provides just compensation when things go wrong. As travellers, we entrust airlines with our belongings, and it’s only fair to expect them to take responsibility when they fail to deliver.
We’d love to hear your thoughts—have you ever experienced damaged luggage or faced challenges with the claims process? Share your experiences in the comments below. Your insights can help raise awareness for a more passenger-friendly system and contribute to improving the travel experience for everyone.
Also read: Streamlined travel between Australia and New Zealand with new airline partnership
