Should brumbies stay in national parks?

Viewing 5 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #1800354
      Jan Fisher
      Keymaster

      A committee commissioned to advise the government on feral horses on public land has found the animals pose a serious threat to endangered species.

      The Threatened Species Scientific Committee submission says the horses are a known threat to 12 animals including fish, frogs and reptiles.

      The report said “We could be looking on the map at a hotspot of extinction that we will regret.

      “We need urgent management action to stop that from happening.”

      Horses on public land are an emotional issue. Images of horses running free tug at the heartstrings and the debate has been polarising over the years.

      Even the greens can’t agree. Some of them want them to be culled and others would prefer they be captured and rehomed.

      That last one seems like magical thinking. Turning any wild animal into a domesticated animal is hard and often futile work.

      And who is going to do it? There are an estimated 18,000-plus horses in the Kosciuszko National Park alone.

      I don’t think there are going to be too many people who could or would take on even one wild horse, let alone the numbers that are out there.

      What do you think should happen to brumbies on public land?

    • #1800435
      Tom Tank
      Participant

      This is very much an emotional issue but looking at it from the point of view of the damage being caused the brumbies must go. They are a feral species and are causing too much damage.

    • #1800475
      Marten
      Participant

      I wholeheartedly agree with Tom Tank. They are feral and are not part of the Australian landscape. In my opinion they are also very destructive of the pristine environment.

    • #1800521
      coaster lady
      Participant

      The brumbies were there for decades before the government made the land national parks. If their presence caused all the so-called damage they claim, why has the environment survived all this time? This big lie is being promoted by a movement who have no concern for the truth but it has become a battle to win at any cost. The numbers of brumbies are guessed by these people and they will use this lie to convince the public the brumbie numbers are extreme. There are not many left due to slaughtering and fires. The predictive numbers they estimate is impossible as not every live brumbie is a female and, at the most, will only have one foal a year. Compared to feral pigs who have litters, the brumby number increase is very slow. The advantages of land regeneration by the brumbie far outweigh any destruction argument.

    • #1800538
      Connie
      Participant

      There are not a lot of Brumbies in the Natural parks so many have been killed all ready & they should be left to roam the mountains in the parks the government having killed so many braumbies all ready & I totally agree with coaster lady comments they do not do the amount of damage the has been stated…. So to the government leave what is left of the brumbies to live in peace…

    • #1800557
      Tood
      Participant

      Hands off the brumbies, deal the the feral human garbage instead!

Viewing 5 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.