As we age, the importance of having reliable health insurance becomes ever more apparent. It’s a safety net that many of us rely on to cover the costs of medical care, which can be exorbitant. However, a concerning trend has emerged that may be hitting the wallets of Australians harder than expected. Insurers have been caught out in what’s being called ‘price gouging’, with secret premium hikes that are leaving many of us out of pocket.
The practice in question is known as ‘product phoenixing,’ a loophole that some health insurance companies are exploiting to raise costs for their customers. While insurers are only permitted to increase premiums once a year with the federal health minister’s approval, some are skirting this rule by discontinuing old policies and introducing nearly identical ones at a higher price. This sneaky tactic is not only unfair but also makes it difficult for customers to compare prices and switch insurers, effectively trapping them in a more expensive plan.
The Commonwealth Ombudsman’s report has shed light on this underhanded strategy, revealing that millions of Australians have been affected. On average, new customers are paying an additional $38 per month in premiums and a whopping $184 more in excess fees. This is a significant financial burden, especially for those on fixed incomes or managing retirement budgets.
Health Minister Mark Butler has not minced words, calling the practice a ‘sleight of hand’ and a ‘largely secret’ way of raising prices. The impact is particularly felt in ‘gold’ tier insurance policies, which cover essential services such as maternity and mental health care. In one egregious example, an insurer hiked the price of a gold policy by 21 per cent in 2023 and then again by 14 per cent in 2024.
The Australian Private Hospitals Association has echoed the sentiment of frustration, pointing out that while insurers are profiting, hospitals are struggling, and public waiting lists are growing. The private health sector is in crisis, with private hospitals closing their doors as insurance companies fail to fully fund members’ care.
The federal health minister has made it clear that the industry operates with significant taxpayer support, including the private health insurance rebate, and must respect its social license. He has urged insurers to clean up their act or face legislative action.
Private Healthcare Australia, the peak industry body, has acknowledged the government’s concerns and has committed to working towards a solution. However, they also highlight the challenges of providing affordable products in an environment where healthcare costs are rising due to an aging population and inflation.
Have you noticed any changes in your health insurance premiums recently? How are you planning to adjust your budget to manage these costs? Share your experiences and any advice you have in the comments—let’s learn from each other and navigate these changes together.
Also read: Surging insurance costs are driving thousands of borrowers to breach their mortgage contracts
